Bald Eagle Roofs & Exteriors Logo

Good, Better, and Best Roof Shingle Differences

December 16, 2024

When considering different shingle replacement options, it's important to understand the quality and durability of the materials involved. Here's a breakdown of the three levels you mentioned:

Good Shingle Replacement

  • Material: Typically involves standard 3-tab asphalt shingles.


  • Durability: Offers basic protection against the elements, but may have a shorter lifespan compared to higher-quality options.



  • Cost: Generally the most affordable option.

Better Shingle Replacement

  • Material: Often involves architectural shingles, which offer a more aesthetically pleasing appearance and improved durability.


  • Durability: Provides enhanced protection against wind, hail, and other weather conditions.



  • Cost: More expensive than standard 3-tab shingles but still a cost-effective choice.

Best Shingle Replacement

  • Material: May include premium architectural shingles or even more specialized roofing materials like metal or tile.


  • Durability: Offers superior protection, longer lifespan, and potential energy efficiency benefits.



  • Cost: The most expensive option, but often justifies the higher cost with its long-term benefits.

It's important to note that these are general guidelines, and the specific materials and costs can vary depending on factors like your location, roof size, and local market conditions.

When making your decision, consider the following factors:


  • Your budget: Determine how much you're willing to spend on your roof replacement.


  • Your home's style: Choose a material that complements your home's architecture.


  • Your local climate: Select a material that can withstand the specific weather conditions in your area.


  • Your long-term goals: Consider the lifespan and maintenance requirements of different materials.


By carefully evaluating these factors, you can choose the best shingle replacement option for your home.

A close up of a roof with a lot of tiles on it.
By Bald Eagle Roofing April 11, 2025
Brava Roof Shingles are synthetic roofing products designed to replicate the appearance of traditional materials such as slate, cedar shake and Spanish clay tiles.
A close up of a roof with a lot of shingles on it.
By Bald Eagle Roofing April 11, 2025
Brava Roof Shingles are synthetic roofing products designed to replicate the appearance of traditional materials such as slate, cedar shake, and Spanish clay tiles.
A white TPO membrane roof with trees in the background on a sunny day.
April 1, 2025
Here at Bald Eagle Roofs and Exteriors, LLC, our goal is to educate homeowners like you about all aspects of the roofing industry. That’s why we’ll be giving you the knowledge needed to make the best purchasing decision for your flat roof.
An aerial shot of a brown EPDM roof.
April 1, 2025
Bald Eagle Roofs and Exteriors Roofing takes pride in providing transparent roofing advice to give homeowners confidence when making decisions. That’s why we want to break down everything you need to know about EPDM roofing membranes.
A roof with a chimney on top of it
December 16, 2024
Here's a breakdown of good, better, and best roof underlayment for shingles, considering factors like durability, water resistance, and ease of installation:
A plane is flying over a building with a blue sky in the background.
December 16, 2024
Here's a breakdown of the features that differentiate a good, better, and best new roof:
A house with a metal roof and a lot of windows
December 16, 2024
Home insurance can cover the cost of a new roof, but it depends on several factors, including the cause of the damage, your policy type, and the specific coverage details. Here’s a breakdown:
An aerial view of a house with a brown roof
December 16, 2024
Do you have a metal roof, or are you interested in one? Are you wondering if it needs to be maintained like asphalt shingles? Just like your car needs maintenance, your roof does, too. However, metal roofing is a little different from other roofing materials.
A house with a metal roof and a blue sky in the background.
December 13, 2024
Metal roofing has become the new big thing in the residential roofing industry. Some reports even say metal roofing will replace asphalt roofing as the most popular material.
Share by: